Case study analysis of laser-assisted Low-Cost Automation assembly | EN

“The results of the case study research were high values of perceived effectiveness, efficiency and system usability for the laser-assisted assembly station in the manufacturing scenario.” 

 

Authors 

Ralf Müller-Polyzou, Nicolas Meier, Anthimos Georgiadis 

Source

IFAC-PapersOnLine, 53(2), 2020, pp. 10403–10410. DOI: 10.1016/j.ifacol.2020.12.2780 

 

Objective 

To evaluate the perceived effectiveness, efficiency and usability of a laser-assisted Low-Cost Automation (LCA) assembly station integrated into a cyber-physical system (CPS), and to derive design principles for user-centred assembly workplaces. 

Methods 

Three case studies were conducted: two at the Digital Factory of Leuphana University Lüneburg and one at the Motek trade fair. In total, 45 valid participant questionnaires were analyzed. Participants assembled a configurable model car using laser guidance and synchronized instructions on a monitor. RFID technology linked the selected product variant to its digital work plan and recorded assembly progress. The university studies combined the System Usability Scale (SUS), adapted After-Scenario Questionnaire (ASQ) items, and structured observation. The trade fair study used a shorter ASQ-based questionnaire. Findings were analyzed to derive practical system design principles. 

Results 

Across the two university studies, involving 22 participants, the assembly station achieved a mean SUS score of 81.1 out of 100. Perceived effectiveness averaged 3.23 and perceived efficiency 3.05 on scales from 0 to 4. Overall, 95.5% of participants showed no difficulties using the system; 68.2% completed the assembly without errors and 27.3% made one error. In the Motek study, all 23 respondents agreed or strongly agreed that they were satisfied with the ease of task completion and the time required. Satisfaction with the supporting information reached 87%. Suggested improvements included clearer parts identification, better monitor positioning and automatic quality control. 

Conclusion 

The case studies indicate that well-designed laser-assisted systems can achieve high perceived usability, effectiveness, and efficiency. Five design principles emphasize integration with existing automation infrastructure, reliable system communication, selective automation upgrades, ergonomic and user-centered design, and coordinated work instructions. Further evaluation with industrial assembly workers would strengthen the findings and their generalizability. 

Retour en haut de page