Efficiency and usability of industrial laser assistance systems in composite preforming – A comparative user study | EN

“A central result of the study is that a time saving of 45.4 % can be achieved by using the laser system.” 

 

Authors 

Hannah Dammers, Yanick Schlesinger, Ralf Müller-Polyzou, Maximilian Kehr, Marius-Konstantin Wiche, Philipp Huber, Thomas Gries 

Source 

SAMPE Europe Conference 2020, Amsterdam. 

 

Objective 

To investigate how industrial laser assistance systems affect production efficiency, placement accuracy, and perceived usability in manual composite preforming compared with conventional plybook instructions. 

Methods 

A comparative user study was conducted at RWTH Aachen University's Institut für Textiltechnik. Eighteen participants, comprising novices, amateurs, and professionals, worked in nine teams of two. Each team performed manual layup tasks on an automotive engine hood mould using both a conventional plybook and a LAP CAD-PRO laser projection system. The layup comprised 20 glass fiber fabric plies of different sizes and geometries. Processing times, positional and angular accuracy were measured. Perceived usability, effectiveness and efficiency were assessed using the System Usability Scale (SUS) and the After-Scenario Questionnaire (ASQ). 

Results 

Laser assistance achieved an average relative time saving of 45.4%, with savings of 40.4% for novices, 47.6% for amateurs and 48.3% for professionals. Positional accuracy improved, particularly for complex and interdependent plies, while angular accuracy showed only a small improvement. The laser system achieved a SUS score of 84.2 out of 100, indicating high perceived usability. On a scale from 0 to 4, perceived effectiveness averaged 3.72 with laser assistance versus 2.00 with the plybook, while perceived efficiency averaged 3.50 versus 1.28. Participants highlighted production speed, process reliability, and ease of work as key benefits. 

Conclusion 

Industrial laser assistance can reduce processing time and improve positional accuracy in manual composite preforming, while providing high perceived usability across different experience levels. The findings support its potential as a flexible assistance system for manufacturing. However, the small, non-representative sample limits the generalization of the results. 

Zum Seitenanfang