Intuitive control of laser-based assembly assistance | EN
“Speech control was the most favorably rated interface in the tested assembly scenario, while the IR remote control achieved the shortest average task completion time.”
Authors
Rainer Müller, Ralf Müller-Polyzou, Leenhard Hörauf, Attique Bashir, Martin Karkowski, Denise Vesper, Steffen Gärtner
Source
ZWF – Zeitschrift für wirtschaftlichen Fabrikbetrieb, 113(6), 2018, pp. 363–368. DOI: 10.3139/104.111922 .
Objective
To evaluate the effectiveness, efficiency, and usability of intuitive control concepts for laser-based assembly assistance, comparing a smartwatch, a gesture-control armband, and speech control with a conventional infrared (IR) remote control.
Methods
The study involved 30 participants from four companies, with 25 complete questionnaire sets included in the analysis. Participants assembled a seven-piece puzzle at a workstation equipped with a LAP CAD-PRO laser projector, using each of the four control concepts. Structured questionnaires captured expectations, perceived effectiveness and efficiency, usability and user experience, incorporating adapted elements of the After-Scenario Questionnaire (ASQ), System Usability Scale (SUS) and meCUE questionnaire. An observer recorded task completion times, input errors, and participant behavior.
Results
Average task completion times were 55 seconds with the IR remote control, 60 seconds with speech control, 61 seconds with the smartwatch and 83 seconds with gesture control. Gesture control produced the highest average number of input errors, at 4.41 per participant. Speech control achieved the highest adapted usability score, at 58.4 out of 80, followed by the smartwatch at 53.5, the IR remote control at 51.5 and gesture control at 33.3. Compared with the IR remote control, participants rated speech control’s perceived effectiveness 10% higher and perceived efficiency 12% higher, although measured task completion was slower. Participants valued speech control for its reliability and hands-free operation.
Conclusion
Speech control was the most favorably rated interface in the tested assembly scenario, while the IR remote control achieved the shortest average task completion time. Gesture control showed the greatest difficulties in usability and task execution. The findings support further investigation of speech control and smartwatch interfaces under real production conditions.
